Trump vs Kamala- Who Will Be Better for India ?

Summary

This video delves into the evolving relationship between the U.S. and India, particularly under the leadership of President Trump versus Vice President Kamala Harris. It highlights Trump’s transactional approach, which fostered cooperation with India despite trade disputes and geopolitical tensions, especially concerning Pakistan and China. The video also touches on India’s diplomatic wins, such as the agreement with China on border issues, and the complexities of navigating its ties with Russia. The speaker asks viewers to consider whether a Trump or Harris presidency would better serve India’s interests in the future.

Takeaways

• 😀 Trump stopped paying Pakistan the $1.3 billion in aid in 2020, signaling a shift in U.S. foreign policy toward Pakistan.
• 😀 The U.S.-India relationship grew stronger under Trump due to shared interests, including opposition to Chinese influence and Trump's transactional nature.
• 😀 India’s decision to ban Chinese apps like TikTok in 2020 was supported by Trump, aligning both countries on concerns over data security and Chinese tech influence.
• 😀 Trump imposed heavy tariffs on steel and aluminum imports, including from India, and ended India's special trade benefits under the GSP program, causing some economic friction.
• 😀 Despite trade tensions, Trump remained open to working with India, valuing business deals over geopolitical ideology, which benefited India in certain areas.
• 😀 Kamala Harris is expected to push India away from Russia due to the ongoing Ukraine conflict, potentially straining the India-U.S. relationship on the geopolitical front.
• 😀 Trump’s approach to geopolitics was less focused on ideological alignments and more on achieving favorable deals for the U.S., which could benefit India in its strategic relations.
• 😀 India’s relationship with Russia, particularly in defense and energy, may face pressure under a Harris administration, contrasting with Trump’s more flexible stance on the matter.
• 😀 India’s strategic role in BRICS is highlighted by its agreement with China on border issues, signaling a diplomatic win for India in negotiations involving Russia and China.
• 😀 The transcript suggests that Trump’s business-first approach might make him a more favorable partner for India compared to Harris, who could align with U.S. interests against Russia.

Q & A

What was the main reason Donald Trump stopped paying aid to Pakistan in 2020?

Donald Trump stopped paying aid to Pakistan in 2020 because of the deteriorating relations between Pakistan and India, following India's ban on Chinese apps like TikTok, which Trump supported due to concerns over data security.

How did India respond to Trump's policy of banning Chinese apps?

India aligned with Trump's decision to ban Chinese apps, viewing it as a security measure to protect its citizens' data, and this alignment helped to strengthen the US-India relationship during that time.

What was the impact of Trump’s tariffs on India in 2018 and 2019?

In 2018, Trump imposed heavy tariffs on steel and aluminum imports, including from India. In 2019, he also ended the Generalized System of Preferences (GSP), which had given India special trade benefits worth $6 billion, affecting Indian exports.

How did Trump's transactional nature affect US-India relations?

Trump's transactional approach to foreign policy, focused on securing business deals rather than engaging in geopolitical complexities, allowed India to maintain a working relationship with the US, especially when India was willing to cooperate with Trump's policies.

What was Trump’s stance on India’s relationship with Russia?

Trump was generally indifferent to India's relationship with Russia, as he was more focused on countering China. He showed less concern about India's energy ties with Russia, which was a point of contention for the US deep state.

How might Kamala Harris’ approach to US-India relations differ from Trump’s?

Kamala Harris is expected to take a tougher stance on Russia and may pressure India to distance itself from Moscow, particularly in the context of the ongoing Ukraine war, which contrasts with Trump's more pragmatic, business-first approach.

What role does Russia play in the relationship between India and China?

Russia played a key role in facilitating a diplomatic breakthrough between India and China, helping India secure a significant agreement to revert to the 2020 borders before the Galwan clash, marking the first time China agreed to return land it had claimed.

What diplomatic message did India send to the US by engaging with China and Russia?

India sent a clear message to the US that by antagonizing India, the US could inadvertently push India closer to China and Russia, which could undermine US interests in the region.

Why does the speaker suggest Trump might be better for US-India relations than Kamala Harris?

The speaker argues that Trump’s transactional nature and willingness to work with India on favorable terms, including on business and strategic issues, may be more beneficial for India compared to Kamala Harris, who is expected to pressure India on human rights and Russia.

What were the key factors that contributed to the strengthening of US-India relations during Trump's presidency?

The strengthening of US-India relations during Trump's presidency was primarily due to shared concerns over China, India's cooperation on trade and security issues, and the alignment of both countries on banning Chinese apps like TikTok for data security reasons.